Common sense: it's what they asked for

Submitted by adam ricketson on Wed, 2009-08-26 17:33.

Glen Greenwald complains about how Glen Beck is presenting himself as a modern day Thomas Paine, by writing his own pamphlet called "Common Sense". I'm not sure exactly what Beck is getting at in the book, but I have no respect for his intellect (though his rants are quite amusing) so I won't be reading it. However, I doubt that Beck and his audience are really ready to hold up Thomas Paine as their mascot.

If you want to read some brilliant writing that contains innovative and profound thoughts (penned by a brave man), check out Pain's writing:

  1. Common Sense: A masterpiece of radical political propaganda. Paine took an idea that had previously seemed like common sense (allegiance to the monarchy) and presented it as pure madness.
  2. Agrarian Justice: An argument for the citizen's dividend funded by a land tax. As a matter of practicality, Paine suggested a lump sum payment to all young adults and regular payments to the elderly, all funded by an inheritance tax (which would effectively be a land tax, since he lived in an agrarian society).
  3. The Age of Reason: A critical examination of Christianity.
  4. Rights of Man: Defending the French Revolution against Burkean criticism.
To top off Paine's anti-conservative credentials, he typically presented elected government as the incarnation of the people's will, and would probably be baffled by the application of "Common Sense" to such a government (but maybe not if he had seen how the American experiment has turned out).

RE: Beck

#7413 On Thu, 2009 08 27 06:07 ka1igu1a said,

IRC, didn't he advocate at one point that Paul supporters were guilty of treason... the guy is all over the map. I don't watch Fox, so i don't watch him, but i looked at the table of contents of his "book" and noted a chapter entitled "The Cancer of Progressivism." I would point out it's the Cancer of progressivism and conservatism. but if he wrote that chapter, then the book wouldn't sell. His objective is to make money... The "cancer" is both progressivism and conservatism divorced from "liberalism," but "liberalism" isn't exactly a selling point with conservatives.

There is a "Common Sense" argument to be made against the technocratic, managerialist State, but it's not going to be Glen Beck, spouting off from the studios of the largest global media coporation in the world, who is going to make that argument.